Lots of Questions

I know I have said I would try to consolidate my thoughts on Hagrid or Minnie McG being evil, and I have not done so on this blog. Suffice it to say, that while my daughter makes fun of me, I have plenty of reasons to think they are.

I think I will start by asking the questions we don't have answers to.

*How did Hagrid find Godric's Hollow?ch 10, PoA

*Hermione's boggart was Minnie McG. Hermione stuttered and said that McG said she'd failed everything. However, in GoF, page 172, McG grabs Hermione around the neck, ostensibly to keep her from falling. It was a tight enough grip that Hermione had to rub her neck. What was that warning for?

*How is it the Minister of Magic, was having a drink with Hagrid, McG and Flitwick? Where was his entourage? PoA .... is this a reason he apologized to Hagrid for taking him away in CoS?

*What did Moody!Crouch mean when he told Ron that his dad'd know all about the Imperius Curse?

**Just how did Peter end up living with the Weasley's?

I have also decided to add Arthur to my list.

He was at the scene of the crime when Moody was kidnapped. Who's to say that he didn't help Crouch Jr? GoF

Pettigrew lived with them, and they even took him on vacation with them to Egypt. (don't forget, Pettigrew was near the open window, by Ron's wand, that time Harry went into the room. Why else would she tell us that, unless she was trying to tell us something?)

There are several good websites that list a lot of reason's for Arthur being under the Imperio.

For that matter... whose side is Percy on?

What if Trelawney isnt' a fraud? I might do a post soon about this one. I do think she is for real now. I think everything she has said has been true. REALLY! Stop thinking about Harry's opinion of her, and see for yourself.
Even the part where she came to Christmas dinner, in PoA, and she predicted the first to rise would be the first to die.

Rowling told us that Dumbledore stood up after she entered, but before she sat down. If you realized that she joined them when she entered the room, then yes, Albus did rise first, and he did die first.

Hmm.. what else? ok.. what does Petunia know? Obviously, waayyyy more than Harry knows she knows.

Why did Voldemort keep telling Lily to stand aside? Why did he call her silly? Why not stupid or Mudblood? There is more than meets the eye there.

Why does Harry have Lily's eyes??? Where is that going?

And I now also purport that James Potter didn't trust Dumbledore. He told him Sirius would be the secret-keeper. Granted, they switched at the last minute, but there must have been a reason. Sure, he told Dumbledore that Sirius was going into hiding also, but even after a few days, why didn't Dumbledore know of the change? Did Dumbledore never get to know the secret of where Godric's Hollow was? Is THIS why he sent Hagrid? It still does not exonerate SOMEONE from knowing Sirius was innocent.

And just exactly why DID Dumbledore have that invisibility cloak? That would have been one of the most important things for James to keep at home, imo. They KNEW there was a spy. Why not keep every advantage with you to protect your family? I find lots of reasons for Albus to have it, and none of them are very good.

Wonder if they used it to get Petunia away from somewhere? I could see Lily wanting to protect her sister, but that isn't the whole answer. What was the whole scoop?

Will Neville break what seems to be a memory charm on him? Just how powerful IS he with his new wand?

And saddly. What if Remus really WAS a spy all along? *ick*

I like Minnie McG, Hagrid, or Arthur better.... for being the hidden bad guy.